Showing posts with label Qantas. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Qantas. Show all posts

Sunday, February 02, 2014

2-Feb-14: In Australia, evidence that Syria's bloodbath is bringing jihad down under

Melburnians old enough to remember when the international airport was located at Essendon might also recall a large advertising sign on Mt Alexander Road which, as we recall it, proclaimed: "Fly Qantas to the World".

The picture of the drinks coaster on the right is the only souvenir we could find on-line of that rather dated commercial message. Growing up in Australia, there really was the sense that Australia was located somewhere just off to the side of the rest of the world, and that from Melbourne and Sydney you needed an airline to get there.

Times have changed. In the Melbourne Age yesterday, a news article ["Al-Qaeda terrorist threat to Australia"] says what observers paying attention to the rising tide of overt sympathy for Islamist jihad will have noted long ago: Australia today faces challenges not so different to those taxing the minds and resources of authorities in Western Europe and Asia. And while the outcome is still uncertain, the results till now are none too encouraging.

The report quotes the US director of national intelligence, James Clapper, who says terrorist organizations connected to Al-Qaeda, already known to be successfully enticing Australians to join the Syrian bloodbath, have established training camps in Syria to provide a basis for terrorist attacks on Australian soil by returning jihadists. Some key points:
  • "As many as 200 Australians are believed to have travelled to Syria to help rebels trying to topple dictator Bashar al-Assad." 
  • "US intelligence has evidence of ''training complexes'' within Syria ''to train people to go back to their countries and conduct terrorist acts''.
  • "About half of the Australians fighting in Syria are believed to be members of Jabhat al-Nusra. Others have joined the Islamic State of Iraq and the Levant (ISIL), an even more militant Islamist group with strong ties to al-Qaeda."
  • A world away from the peaceful Australian
    Gold Coast, Amira Karroum was killed
    alongside her Muslim husband Yusuf Ali
    in Syria [Image Source]
  • Australia's counter-terrorism ambassador Bill Fisher shares the assessment. He says that while "the likelihood of an attack like 9/11 in the West has lessened", the threat of "smaller but nonetheless deadly attacks is very real - hitting bars where Westerners congregate overseas, and other soft targets. In this respect, the threat is worse"...
Australia's awareness of how threats like these translate into tragic outcomes took a startling turn upwards when a jihadi terror attack on a tourist spot in Bali, Indonesia in 2002 cost more than two hundred innocent lives, including those of 88 Australians. [See our contribution in the wake of the tragedy: "11-Oct-07: Kuta beach, five years on"].

Since then, there have been reports and video clips of religious calls to violence by Australian Islamic figures [here, here, here among numerous other instances], violent street demonstrations in Sydney [here, here, here and elsewhere], and front-page reports like this January 2014 article entitled "Amira Karroum was one of many Australians being recruited to fight in Syria" about a young Australian woman who seemed so ordinary, so unremarkable, "the unlikeliest terrorist" until - after her violent death - she is revealed to have written to family:
"Everything is temporary... Islam is my identity. The burqa is my shield. Jannah (the Islamic garden of paradise) is my destination.'' [Telegraph, Sydney, January 18, 2014]
A year ago, Qantas - which faces non-trivial commercial challenges - entered into a strategic partnership with Emirates, a highly successful, well funded airline that is wholly owned by the government of Dubai, a monarchy.

Dubai's government has been wholly controlled by the Al Maktoum family since 1833, entirely untroubled by the need for elections. Qantas, the Al Maktoum business partner, now happily channels much of its Europe-bound traffic via Dubai (concerning which, we posted a string of comments in 2012 and 2013 starting with this one). The volume of passenger and freight traffic between the Middle East and Australia has grown accordingly and is likely to keep doing so. This is going to have an impact. As the Dubai-based on-line journal Arabian Business recently noted:
"Dubai controls strategic trade routes in the world and also more than 65 terminals across the world, including new developments underway in India, Africa, Europe and South America. What this means is, Dubai can influence global trade through these particular ports and have controls over them... Once they implement this and once Dubai starts implementing this in relation to its own trade, what you will see is the beginning of Islamisation that is led by Dubai.” [Arabian Business, October 2, 2013]
Concerns about a Dubai role in the funding of terror get occasional media attention, like this January 2010 piece from The Guardian, "Dubai's dark side targeted by international finance police":
"Fears are intensifying that the emirate has become a global centre for terror funding, money-laundering, drug money and mafia cash..." [The Guardian]
Significant changes have clearly overcome once-isolated Australia's place in the world in the past decade or two. So the notion that religiously motivated terrorists - jihadis - are eyeing far-away places like Australia ought not to be a surprise to anyone. The reality is that neither distant Australia nor anywhere else on earth is far enough away from "the world" to be insulated from the threats that the loathsome jihadists embody.

The warning that hardened Islamist fighters, energized by what they may have seen or done in the slaughter-house that Syria has become, are returning to hospitable Australia with mayhem on their minds ought to continue to get serious attention.

Saturday, June 15, 2013

15-Jun-13: Attention Qantas travelers: A pungent follow-up here to our earlier posts about Emirates, Qantas and Dubai

Click for our earlier posts about Emirates/Qantas
"The World's Leading Airline Partnership" 
In the course of more than thirty posts starting in September 2012, we reflected in this blog on the infuriating saga of Prof. Cyril Karabus and what we termed his Kafka-esque treatment in Dubai at the hands of the United Arab Emirates authorities.

(Click here to see our earlier posts about Emirates/Qantas, "The World's Leading Airline Partnership".)

In the course of analyzing what was being done to him, we noted time and again how Australia's Qantas airline has very recently blended a large part of its operations into the Dubai-based Emirates Airlines. And we warned of what travelers availing themselves of the Emirates/Qantas hookup might encounter in light of the Karabus affair.

Fortunately Prof. Karabus is safely home and we have discontinued our focus on him and his ordeal. But today he is interviewed in Haaretz, and we feel this ought to be more widely disseminated.

Without further ado, here is a direct quote, from "Caught in a Kafka-esque ordeal in Dubai, a South African doctor finally comes home":
...Much of Karabus’s palpable anger is directed at Emirates Airways. He says that just before leaving Canada he was told by airline personnel that there seemed to be a problem with his ticket – some official query from Dubai about him. “I asked what it was and asked them to investigate – and they assured me that it had been resolved. But they knew, they knew, oh yes, that the police were looking for me – and they let me go ahead and fly straight into a trap. What does that mean?” asks Karabus furiously. “It means that the Emirates Airways is an arm of the UAE law enforcement agency. What kind of crap is that?” Various newspapers, notably the Johannesburg Sunday Times, approached Emirates Airways both locally and at its head office to respond to Karabus' accusations. The company said it had nothing to do with Karabus' situation and refused to comment further. [Haaretz]
You can see some of our earlier notes about the implications of an Emirates tie-up for people who, like us, admire Qantas and enjoy flying it but sense something seriously worrying has happened, here.

(No response came to us from either Qantas or Emirates during the nine months of our coverage.)

Tuesday, May 14, 2013

14-May-13: It's being reported that Prof. Cyril Karabus' passport was returned to him today

From the South African News24 site:
Cape Town - 2013-05-14 14:54 | United Arab Emirates (UAE) officials handed back South African doctor Cyril Karabus's passport on Tuesday afternoon, the international relations department confirmed. Spokesperson Clayson Monyela said the passport was handed to the SA embassy around noon. The UAE interior department also issued a letter which would allow Karabus to leave the region. "The SA Embassy in the UAE will tomorrow [Wednesday] morning assist Prof Karabus to obtain the exit visa from the UAE, in view of the fact that the relevant office in the UAE was already closed at the time of receiving his passport," said Monyela. He said Karabus would be assisted with travel arrangements to return to South Africa within the next two days...
Click for some of the posts we have written here during the nine months of Prof. Karabus' shameful and unjustified incarceration at the hands of the United Arab Emirates authorities.

Friday, April 12, 2013

12-Apr-13: Karabus: Some long overdue major international media attention on the Emirates

Good to see the front page of this morning's International Herald Tribune, the international edition of the New York Times, giving some factual attention to the appalling treatment of Prof. Cyril Karabus at the hands of the authorities in Abu Dhabi and Dubai.

Not that there is any expectation of them adjusting their opaque, undemocratic and legally-dysfunctional approach to his improper incarceration, but arousing public opinion by shining some bright light on this little-publicized Emirates scandal can't be a bad thing. That's about the only remaining strategy when authoritarian regimes in dark, press-controlled corners of the Third World engage in their capricious ways with innocent people's freedom.


The New York Times version of the same article which will also appear in Friday's paper edition is headlined "Emirates’ Laws Trap a Doctor Just Passing Through". 

We have written again and again (most recently in "9-Apr-13: Justice, United Arab Emirates style: The outrageous saga continues") on the Emirates/Karabus scandal. It stands for something more than 'merely' a disgraceful example of unchecked absolute power being applied wrongly and unfairly on a powerless victim (endemic in this part of the world). The unlawful actions of the 'authorities' in Abu Dhabi, Dubai and the United Arab Emirates, and the benign way the world's media generally treat them, are part of a much larger issue that affects many more people and not only those who unwittingly visit the UAE. 

You can see some of our earlier comments in a March post of ours [28-Mar-13: He is acquitted but Prof. Karabus "has no choice but to submit"] and via the links embedded in that and earlier This Ongoing War posts. 

Just one more word of a practical nature: we wrote a few days ago that health professionals attracted by the shine and glitz of Dubai and Abu Dhabi and by jobs promoted on sites likethisthisthis and this should be warned ahead of time about just how different the UAE and its authoritarian regimes are from the world they know.

Thursday, March 28, 2013

28-Mar-13: He is acquitted but Prof. Karabus "has no choice but to submit"

South African newspapers have been reporting for some days that Prof. Cyril Karabus, 77, whose involuntary detention by the people who run the United Arab Emirates has been going on now for seven months in defiance of basic principles of due process, has been cleared, acquitted, found not guilty, freed to go home and so on. The spokesperson for South Africa's Department of International Relations and Co-operation broadcast a tweet a week ago exulting (after the earlier intervention of the department's minister) that "He is free!"

So here's today's news. The source is South Africa's Eyewitness News website:
CAPE TOWN - Prosecutors in the United Arab Emirates (UAE) have told Professor Cyril Karabus’ legal team they intend appealing the decision to find him not guilty of manslaughter. Last week, an Abu Dhabi court found the elderly professor not guilty of manslaughter and forgery. A medical committee cleared the paediatric oncologist of all blame for the death of a young cancer patient he treated there more than a decade ago. The latest development means Karabus will remain in the UAE indefinitely...
We have not yet seen any reports originating in the UAE that confirm this, but we will keep looking. And if there is anyone out there still thinking the man's own government is willing to do what ought to be done, think again:
"Professor Cyril Karabus has no choice but to submit to the UAE's legal process, the dept of international relations said on Thursday, after it emerged that he will not be allowed to come back to South Africa yet." [SAPA]
We have posted numerous times here about the Kafkaesque ordeal that this distinguished medico has suffered at the hands of the authorities in the UAE. For a quick overview, we suggest these: "21-Mar-13: Is Prof Karabus finally being released and going home?"; and "29-Jan-13: UAE "Justice" officials fiddle: The scandalous treatment of Prof. Karabus goes on and on".

May we suggest again that anyone planning to travel to or through Dubai should carefully review what we posted here yesterday? See "27-Mar-13: Final call for Australian travelers to London with Qantas". And for the record, the advice is not meant only for Australians.

This outrageous affair is barely known outside South Africa. It's time to change that.

Wednesday, March 27, 2013

27-Mar-13: Final call for Australian travelers to London with Qantas

"UAE Vice President, Prime Minister and Ruler of Dubai His Highness Sheikh Mohammed bin Rashid Al Maktoum inspects headquarters of Dubai Police, February 15, 2011. Greeting him is Commander General of Dubai Police Lt. General His Excellency Dahi Khalfan Tamim, senior officers and a group of children bearing flowers." [Image Source: His Highness' personal website]
Professor Cyril Karabus, whose Kafkaesque imprisonment (on charges of murder and forgery) without trial in the UAE began in August 2012 is now said to be adjudged innocent according to reports in the past few days. Despite this, as of today, the 77 year-old retired paediatric oncologist has yet to receive back his passport from the authorities in Abu Dhabi, is therefore still unable to leave the UAE, and cannot yet fly home to South Africa. 

We will hold off on further analysis of what has been done to him until he is safely out of the UAE.

Meanwhile, Australia's airline QANTAS received approval today from Australia's competition regulator, the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission, to form an alliance with the UAE airline, Emirates. Qantas is going to use Dubai rather than Singapore as its stopover point for Qantas flights to London. The first of those Qantas flights to London via Dubai is due to depart this Sunday. It's a deal that was signed in September 2012; the commission's approval arrived with mere days to spare. 

It's said to be economically vital to the future of Qantas, as its chief executive has taken pains to explain over and again; the injection of United Arab Emirates cash and facilities are key to Qantas's efforts to return to profitability. But note that although the agreement between the airlines is for a term of ten years, in the end they received regulatory approval for only five. The deal will have to pass another round of review in 2018. Meanwhile, what will be, will be.

Media coverage of the Qantas/Emirates alliance offers subtle but significant hints as to the cultural differences between the Emirates and the west. Reuters reporting from Sydney points out that in addition to ACCC cutting the "the desired alliance timeframe" in half (to 5 years), it determined that the deal would produce "material, but not substantial" public benefits. No sign of that hesitation appears in the comprehensive report appearing in the Abu Dhabi newspaper, The National, today.

As friends keep telling us, Dubai has a name for being all business, shopping and luxury, with everything else - politics, religion, social conventions - taking a back seat. Does this make Dubai, or any other part of the entirely-undemocratic UAE, some kind of gold-plated laissez-faire paradise? Hardly. People who get on the wrong side of those in charge in Dubai, Abu Dhabi and other corners of the UAE have very few of the options or rights to due process that westerners take for granted

The U.S. State Department said in a 2010 report that Dubai's constitution "guarantees an independent judiciary", in reality it is the "political leadership” that makes decisions and "defendants can spend months without being charged and are often unfairly denied bail."

What else should travelers know about going there? Quite a lot, actually. A startling article by Robert Upe, a travel and tourism writer, in the Melbourne Age/Sydney Morning Herald yesterday, provides some practical guidance. It's called "Don't kiss, don't swear: rules of a Dubai stopover", and its timing is driven by the start of the Qantas romance with the desert airline. And for the record, the threats go way beyond kissing and swearing

Some highlights of the Dubai/UAE experience:
Dubai metro: "Don't take offence, don't continue to try
and sort something out, simply hand it over to a male
colleague... The fact that he is male will make all the difference
.'' [Image Source]
  • Australia's Federal Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade warns on its website that de facto relationships, homosexual relationships and acts of adultery and prostitution are subject to severe punishment.
  • It is an offence "to share the same hotel room with someone of the opposite sex to whom you are not married or closely related".
  • In a tortuous circumlocution, DFAT warns that "Australian travellers of Jewish background who are Israeli passport holders" are allowed to pass through Dubai. But leaving the airport is strictly verboten. This is because the UAE is an active participant in "the Arab League boycott of Israel". That boycott is itself illegal in several parts of the world; the US government's Office of Antiboycott Compliance (part of the U.S. Department of Commerce) keeps a watchful eye out for businesses that quietly, but illegally, go along with the Arab league's efforts. And for the record, the boycott was created to deter Jewish immigration into what is now the State of Israel long before the state was proclaimed in the wake of a UN decision in 1947. The Arab League formalized the boycott right after the 1948 Arab-Israeli War when there were zero (so-called) occupied territories and no security barrier. The UAE's continuing compliance with the boycott is an egregious reminder of how much nonsense is used to justify anti-Israel and anti-Jewish activities in so many quarters.
  • "Cultural misdemeanours", meaning holding hands in public, swearing, harassing women with a prolonged stare, wearing inappropriate clothing, may result in imprisonment or judicial fines.
  • Qantas says Jewish and Israeli passengers will be safe transiting through Dubai as long as they don't plan of stepping outside the building. But then what happens "in the event of a catastrophe or severe weather when airport hotels are full?'', asks Radha Stirling of the non-profit Detained in Dubai organization. Operating under the mantra "Detained in Dubai exists to free people from the chains of injustice", the group helps people in "legal difficulty" in the United Arab Emirates. Qantas travelers might want to write its phone number inside their passports just in case. No, on reflection, it might be better to put somewhere safer than that. The number of their London office is +44 7050 686 745
  • Detained in Dubai points out that getting into serious trouble in Dubai/UAE is easy: ''Just one person needs to take offence and to make a complaint and you can be in serious trouble and be held in custody for a long time if you challenge the charge."
  • Drinking in public "can land travellers in strife", says Upe. 
  • Qantas has been putting its staff through what the article calls "cultural training". The key take-away: "Customer issues with UAE passengers may be best solved by a man. Don't take offence, don't continue to try and sort something out, simply hand it over to a male colleague. It doesn't matter whether you are the manager or supervisor, the fact that he is male will make all the difference.''
  • And if you don't do well with that whole 'cultural training' aspect? So here are a few outcomes mentioned in the article that travelers might want to think about: A British couple were jailed for three months in 2008 after having drunken sex on a public beach. A different British couple were arrested in 2010 and sentenced to a month in jail for kissing in public in Dubai. In 2009, an Australian man was arrested for allegedly saying “What the f---?” to a plainclothes police officer who grabbed his arm at Dubai Airport. He was forced to remain in Dubai for months before being let go with a fine.
  • The Age/SMH article offers the following helpful guidelines that originate with Dubai's Department of Tourism and Commerce Marketing. Offensive language, spitting, aggressive behaviour and smoking outside designated areas are not tolerated. Public displays of affection such as holding hands or kissing are not tolerated. Men should avoid staring at local women or attempting to make eye contact. During Ramadan while Muslims are fasting from dawn to dusk, non-Muslims can only eat  and drink in screened-off areas in many hotels and restaurants.
Finally, bear in mind that when the senior Hamas figure, Mahmoud al-Mabhouh, was assassinated under murky and still unresolved circumstances in February 2010, he was free to enter, move around and base himself in Dubai without any evident concern about security or legal matters. Notwithstanding the sharp focus on making money, Dubai appears to set no great barriers in the path of active terrorists. How consistent or conflicting this is with the guidelines above is a matter that readers, especially those who are eligible to enter the place (unlike us), may want to ponder.

Wednesday, February 27, 2013

27-Feb-13: This is what falling into the clutches of a non-democratic political entity run on non-transparent principles can do to people

Prof. Cyril Karabus, held without trial by the "authorities" in the UAE for more than six months
For readers who have been following the horror of the United Arab Emirates' treatment of the frail retired South African paediatric oncologist Prof. Cyril Karabus, here is today's installment of the ongoing disgrace.

UAE panel yet to send report in South African doctor's manslaughter case
Haneen Dajani | The National | Feb 27, 2013 |  ABU DHABI // The medical committee examining the case of the South African doctor accused of manslaughter has not sent its report yet, the criminal court has announced. Cyril Karabus, 77, was convicted in absentia of murder and forgery, accused of causing the death in 2002 of a three-year-old Yemeni girl suffering cancer. His retrial on charges of manslaughter and forgery has been stranded in court for months awaiting the medical committee’s report, as well as a medical file requested by the defence. The paediatric oncologist, who denies the charge, has been on bail with his passport confiscated since October. He was arrested at Dubai airport in August while travelling with his family. Last month South Africa sent a démarche – a strong protest – to the UAE Government calling for the case against Karabus to be expedited. The case was adjourned until March 20 pending the committee’s report.
There will be plenty of time to drag the princelings of the oil-soaked UAE and their minions through the global court of public opinion at some appropriate time in the future. But right now, today, who is going to get this poor, unjustly detained man out of their clutches?

Some selected background for those new to this sickening and grossly under-reported affair:

Wednesday, February 06, 2013

6-Feb-13: At the United Arab Emirates foreign ministry, they want you to know their hands are tied

The updated Karabus page on the UAE foreign ministry website
Here's an update to our posting of a week ago ["31-Jan-13: UAE's foreign ministry is "closely following" Prof. Karabus' nightmare"] about how the diplomats of Dubai and Abu Dhabi are seeking to soft pedal the disgraceful treatment being meted out as we speak to the distinguished retired South African doctor, Prof. Cyril Karabus. [For links to the background - see the end of this post.]

Visitors to the UAE foreign ministry website will have seen a short, even terse, statement about Prof. Karabus' case, highlighting the offences with which he is charged in relation to a three year old patient: "failing to give her a blood transfusion" and "forging a medical report". There's little there of an informative nature other than the headline which may leave some readers wondering what sort of "closely following" the UAE's diplomats are doing if they fail to take account of the long list of deeply disturbing aspects of the Karabus case we mentioned in our post.

Readers who go back to the UAE foreign ministry's website now will see a longer treatment of the Karabus case. Under the identical headline, they have added words and sentences but neither insight nor honesty; it's just self-justification of a kind that many will find distasteful. The key addition is this specious argument:
As is the case in South Africa, the judicial process in the United Arab Emirates is independently and wholly overseen and managed by the Federal Supreme Court.  The Government of the United Arab Emirates cannot and does not interfere in the independent judicial process. 
The UAE Constitution states that: “All persons are equal before the law, without distinction between citizens of the Federation in regard to race, nationality, religious belief and social status”.  Professor Karabus will be tried on this basis and in accordance with international standards. 
The Ministry of Foreign Affairs of the UAE will continue to keep South African Authorities up to date with developments regarding this matter
The Ministry of Foreign Affairs understands the difficulties involved for the family of any person who is on trial, especially when a trial is taking place in a country that is not their own. However, it is imperative that the proper judicial process is followed
We think the double-talking and hypocrisy of these foreign office apologetics speak far more eloquently than the pseudo-diplomatic tone. 

The frail 77 year-old doctor who was originally prosecuted in his absence without ever being notified of the charges or afterwards of the conviction, has been a prisoner of the UAE since August 2012. The prosecutors have still not produced the evidence file and his case has been adjourned without a substantive hearing 16 times. 

The crushing injustice of the Karabus case shines a harsh light on how life is lived in those oil-and-money-drenched corners of the world where democracy, open government and legal due process are far-off and foreign notions. In the UAE, you can get your hands on most things that money can buy. But that has never included justice or decency, not even in their bursting-at-the-seams duty-free shops.

Some of our previous posts about this painful subject for your further reading:

Thursday, January 31, 2013

31-Jan-13: UAE's foreign ministry is "closely following" Prof. Karabus' nightmare

A question:
Have you noticed how it is that when you personally know something about an event or a person, and then that event or person is written up in a newspaper article or a TV program, and you read it or watch it, and you sit there pretty much amazed that the people at the newspaper or TV program have misconstrued or completely misrepresented the facts and turned the thing that you know entirely on its head and gotten really important parts wrong or failed to say things that are so important that without telling them the whole narrative makes no sense?
Yes, so have we. Again and again.

Why do we ask?

First, because we know from checking our visitors' log that there are many South Africans (but not so many from Dubai and Abu Dhabi) who have been reading our blog in recent weeks to get updated on the scandalous way in which the distinguished paediatric oncologist, Prof. Cyril Karabus from Capetown, is being treated by the justice and law enforcement officials in the United Arab Emirates where he has been held prisoner since August.

And since they (and our regular readers) know something about the outrageous treatment to which this frail 78 year old with a decades-long history of saving children's lives has been subjected, we want them to see the way in which the UAE's government - in perhaps the first public indication that it holds a viewpoint on the Karabus scandal - recounts what has been happening.

So here's our point.

If you go to the website of the foreign ministry of the United Arab Emirates right now [here it is], you will see the following report which appears, as well, on the ministry's home page as part of a series of revolving stories right at the top. (In other words, for some reason they really want people to know what we are about to show you.)


Here's the full and unedited text:
The Ministry of Foreign Affairs is closely following the case of the South African oncologist | 30 January 2013 | The Ministry of Foreign Affairs is closely following the case of Professor Cyril Karabus, the South African oncologist accused of causing a young girl’s death by failing to give her a blood transfusion whilst undergoing treatment at Sheikh Khalifa Medical City.
Professor Karabus is also accused of forging a medical report. Professor Karabus was originally tried in absentia in 2004 and found guilty.
Following his arrest that original ruling was overturned in order that he stand trial in person.
Seems like a fair enough representation of reality, right?

No, it's not.

The people at the Ministry of Foreign Affairs who are closely following this could have mentioned but did not that Prof. Karabus had never been informed of any criminal charges laid against him, had therefore never been given an opportunity to defend his good name and was never informed that a UAE sharia court had  convicted him on charges of forgery (forgery!) and offences connected with the death of a three-year-old terminally ill patient from Yemen back in the year 2000.

Flying back home to South Africa after his son's wedding in Canada in August 2013, he was taken from the transit lounge at Dubai airport by UAE police to a notorious prison and locked up there for eight weeks. He made multiple applications for bail and was refused multiple times until it was granted eight weeks after his arrest. His passport remains with the law enforcement officials of the UAE so that they can ensure the pensioner with a heart pacemaker cannot easily flee.

He remains a prisoner of the UAE until today. The court that has control of his criminal trial has adjourned the matter 16 times so far. Instead of letting him go home on the basis that the prosecution has been completely unable to prove its case against him or show him the medical file on the basis of which the charges were presented, he was informed two days ago [see our report] that this Kafkaesque nightmare goes on, and the next hearing,  postponed yet again, is set for February 27.

The details of this intersection between a decent and heroic man's life and the law and order system of the United Arab Emirates could - and surely will - fill books, magazine articles and television programs once he is out and free.

Meanwhile, even before he is set free, we feel a moral obligation to highlight several aspects of this shocking affair in the hope that there will be an uproar against the people responsible.
  1. The British Medical Association published an angry letter of protest dated December 14, 2012 and sent to the Minister of Justice in Abu Dhabi. The full text is here. It ends with this demand: "As the prosecution is unable to present any substantive evidence against Prof Karabus, he should be released from effective detention immediately and all charges dropped. In our view continuing effectively to detain Prof Karabus in these circumstances amounts to a fundamental violation of Prof Karabus’ human rights, and any trial in these circumstances will fail to meet international standards of fairness and would lead to widespread condemnation."
  2. A published advice [here] from the South African Medical Association (SAMA) reminds medical professionals that the UAE is 'heavily dependent' on foreign doctors to support its healthcare system. The ongoing incarceration of the distinguished Prof. Karabus is a reminder to its members to 'think carefully' before working in the UAE. SAMA suggested a global professional boycott of countries "which treat health professionals in such a manner". 
  3. Qantas, Australia's international airline, is about to merge a significant part of its global operations with Emirates, a UAE airline. Australians transiting through Dubai in the future, en route to Europe and London ought to know something about the risks they face, as exemplified by the nightmare inflicted on Prof. Karabus. If it can happen to a man in his late seventies in poor health and with his proud achievements, it can certainly happen to the rest of us.
  4. As we mentioned in a previous posting, a South African publication called The Daily Maverick reported back in November that the Karabus family had asked Emirates, the UAE airline, to consider funding tickets for them to travel to Prof. Karabus in Abu Dhabi as a goodwill gesture and to make it a little easier for them to give him the support he needs. Emirates declined, saying: “This is a legal issue being dealt with by the relevant authorities and does not involve Emirates.” It's a point that Qantas passengers and management might want to take on board and ponder.
If anyone from, or on behalf of, the Ministry of Foreign Affairs of the United Arab Emirates has looked closely into these aspects too, and has an opinion they are willing to share with us, we will be glad to provide them with a global platform right here.

Some of our previous posts about this painful subject for your further reading:

26-Sep-12: Dubai, Dubai, Dubai

Tuesday, January 29, 2013

29-Jan-13: A development in the scandalous UAE 'prosecution' of Prof. Karabus

The UAE Ministry of Justice website
From a South African news source this morning:
The professor’s Cape Town-based attorney Michael Bagraim said prosecutors indicated they intend dropping the forgery charge. “If one has no hope of a forgery charge, the manslaughter charge has no traction at all because the one flows from the other.” This move has yet to be sanctioned by the judge. The retired paediatric oncologist is facing a charge of manslaughter following the death of a cancer patient he treated at the Sheikh Khalifa Medical Centre in the United Arab Emirates (UAE) over a decade ago. But state officials in Abu Dhabi have been struggling to find the patient's original medical records. Karabus’ case has been in limbo for weeks after an Abu Dhabi judge postponed it indefinitely. But the 77-year-old, who is out on bail, is still not allowed to leave the UAE.
See the most recent of our posts ["24-Jan-13: Time for the United Arab Emirates to know the world is watching"] for the background to this thoroughly disgraceful affair. Beyond that, and until Prof. Karabus has his liberty and passport restored to him, we will refrain from making the kind of comment that this development would normally call for.

By the way, as we keep asking, is anyone from Qantas paying attention?

UPDATE: There's more. See our Tuesday midday report: "29-Jan-13: UAE "Justice" officials fiddle: The scandalous treatment of Prof. Karabus goes on and on"

Thursday, January 24, 2013

24-Jan-13: Time for the United Arab Emirates to know the world is watching

About an hour ago, we received a promotional mailer from Qantas, of whose frequent flyer club we have been members for years. It announces (again) the impending merger with Emirates and all the good things to follow for travelers who passing through Dubai on QF's London and Europe-bound flights.

We mention this in the context of a traveler who did pass through Dubai half a year ago and unwittingly entered into a Kafkaesque descent into physical privation, financial pressure, humiliation, existential fear and the almost complete loss of his freedom in the literal sense of all those terms.

The affair at the heart of this call is so starkly unjust as to make you think it was scripted in Hollywood. But the central figure, the victim, is no actor. He is a retired professor of medicine whose professional career was replete with lives of children saved, public hospitals successfully run, medical milestones achieved, and years of quiet dedication to the urgent needs of pediatric patients from all strata of South African society during and after the apartheid era.

The outrageous, high-handed treatment of this beloved medical hero at the hands of the police and the courts in Abu Dhabi entered a new phase yesterday. This is the result of a request from a Cape Town lawyer calling for action against the authorities in the United Arab Emirates.

Professor Cyril Karabus did not know it at the time. But when he accepted an offer to do a brief locum (a temporary medical posting) in a UAE hospital more than a decade ago, he set in motion a series of shocking events that eventually left him shackled at his court appearances, and forced to sleep on the bare concrete floor of a prison (Al Wathba) notorious for its torture practices. Did we mention that he is 78? And has a cardiac pacemaker?

We have reported on the deeply troubling affair several times since September 2012 including these blog posts:
To recap briefly: 
Prof. Karabus, traveling with his wife, was arrested on August 17. 2012, while traveling via Dubai  back to his home in South Africa after celebrating his son's wedding in Canada. The UAE authorities seized his passport (which has still not been returned) as he entered the transit lounge and notified him that he had been tried and convicted of manslaughter and of falsifying documents without ever having been told about it. A three-year-old terminally ill child from Yemen whom he treated at the Sheikh Khalifa Medical Centre in Abu Dhabi in 2002 had died, and without being put on trial or getting so much as a telegram about the charges, he was convicted, sentenced to four years of imprisonment, and ordered to pay a huge sum of cash which UAE law calls - without embarrassment - 'blood money'. Taken from the transit lounge of one of the most opulent airports in the world, he spent months locked up in a notorious Abu Dhabi prison, known for its human rights violations. After numerous unproductive court appearances and being obliged to pay a financial bond (equal to 240,000 Rand or about US$27,000), he was granted bail in mid-October but required to remain within the emirate. He has had fifteen hearing dates in a court where no English is spoken, and where the state prosecution continues - until today - to be unable to locate the file on the basis of which the charges were brought. Lawyers familiar with the case say there is no possible way for him to be convicted in these circumstances. But he remains an unwilling 'guest' of the United Arab Emirates, burning through what remains of his retirement funds, paying for lawyers, living costs and travel expenses for family members while the UAE legal system looks away and busies itself with protecting its dignity. The entire affair is an obnoxious disgrace to the good name of law and justice.
Now this, from South Africa's Cape Argus newspaper, yesterday - January 22, 2013 ["Prof’s legal team urges boycott of Abu Dhabi"]
Cape Town Professor Cyril Karabus’s legal team has called on event organisers across the globe to reconsider hosting events in Abu Dhabi in a move to put pressure on the United Arab Emirates authorities. Karabus’s lawyer Michael Bagraim said the legal team had asked several organisations responsible for hosting events such as sports tournaments and oil and gas seminars in Abu Dhabi to boycott the country.
“We are trying a different approach that will apply pressure internally. We are asking businesses and organisations to consider boycotting the country as they (Abu Dhabi) are unfairly holding Karabus,” he said. [more]
And this ["Boycott United Arab Emirates, health professionals told" - January 22, 2013]:
Urging health professionals to stop applying for jobs in the UAE, Dr Mzukisi Grootboom, chairperson of the SA Medical Association, said: “This is for your own safety. We advise South African doctors and other health professionals to avoid working in the UAE. We ask that those already there to consider withdrawing their services in the interest of their own safety.” [more]
Sheikh Khalifa medical center: Do the glitz and oil wealth of
Dubai, Abu Dhabi and the UAE allow outrageous abuses
to escape notice?
If there is a version of this sordid narrative that is kinder to the UAE, then its officials are doing an exceedingly poor job of stating it. The impression is they don't give a damn - not about the professor, not about their international reputation. Assuming the facts are as they appear to be, Prof. Karabus is the innocent victim of a heavy-handed system that bears little resemblance to modern notions of justice and due process. As soon as it became clear that the prosecutors lacked the most basic files needed for their case, he should have been handed back his passport along with a personal apology from the appropriate senior official in charge of an out-of-control justice system, given assurances of appropriate financial compensation, and sent home flying first-class with Emirates Airlines.

Speaking of Emirates Airline, which is in the process of becoming Qantas' senior partner, consider what another South African publication wrote in November ["The Abu Dhabi nightmare continues for Dr Karabus"]
South Africa’s Treatment Action Campaign (TAC) has been particularly vocal in lobbying for Karabus’s release. In a statement released on Monday, it criticised the handling of the case by the Department of International Relations and Cooperation... The TAC has also targeted Emirates Airline for criticism, as Karabus was flying Emirates when arrested. “We are astonished that the airline failed to warn Professor Karabus that he was wanted in the UAE,” it said. Sarah Karabus says that at the beginning of their journey in Toronto, airline staff informed them that there was some form of security alert attached to her father’s name, but would not elaborate, and certainly gave no sense of its severity. Sarah says that her family asked Emirates if it would consider funding tickets for them to visit Karabus in Abu Dhabi as a goodwill gesture, but it declined. When the Daily Maverick approached Emirates Airline for comment, it was told: “This is a legal issue being dealt with by the relevant authorities and does not involve Emirates.”
Boycott or not, that's the sort of shameful statement we think Qantas customers need to hear. If this is what the people in Emirates' hometown can do right in the midst of their bright, shiny super-luxury airport terminal to people of Prof. Karabus' stature, then who is safe?

Frankly, we are not much in favour of boycotts, but we do believe in loud and clear protests when the mainstream news media fail to report on injustice and oppression. That's certainly the case with Prof. Karabus' ongoing plight. His friends and supporters are now upping the stakes and have spoken with the SA media about their evolving campaign [see "Bagraim brings a world of pain down on Emirates"]. They should be supported as widely as possible.

If you have business connections in Abu Dhabi or Dubai, or if you happen to own Qantas, this is the time to speak out and let the faceless representatives of UAE justice know the world is watching.

Wednesday, January 02, 2013

2-Jan-13: For readers concerned with what is still being done to a distinguished healer of children with cancer

Emirates chairman Sheikh Ahmed bin Saeed al-Maktoum [Image Source]
For our many readers who are interested in the outcome of today's hearing in the outrageous criminal case brought against the elderly and distinguished paediatric oncologist, Prof. Cyril Karabus in a United Arab Emirates sharia court.

We don't know much more than the following in which The National, a newspaper published in Abu Dhabi, says that earlier today (Wednesday):
Prosecutors were once more unable to produce the original hospital files, prompting the judge to remove the case from the court's roll and order them to restate their case. They must now either present the documents or drop the charges. Meanwhile, the professor will remain on bail. His passport was handed in as a condition of bail. The judge did not set another date.
In August 2012, Prof. Karabus was an unsuspecting passenger on Emirates Airlines, returning to South Africa after his son's wedding in Canada, and transiting through Dubai airport when he was arrested and thrown into a UAE jail notorious for the harsh conditions in which prisoners, many of them charged with being terrorists, are kept. The charge sheet referred to his having been convicted of culpability in the death of a terminally ill child a decade earlier. He had never been informed of those charges or of the fact that he had been convicted.

We have been tracking this disgraceful affair because of the screaming injustice - not in itself an unusual phenomenon in that part of the world - that it represents, but also because Qantas, the great Australian airline, is about to start shunting thousands of London-bound passengers via the UAE as a result of its new tie-up with Emirates (both the airline and the statelet). For links to previous posts, "25-Dec-12: The Emirates scandal: the missing evidence turns up".

Most Australians have no idea what kind of life and dangers go on behind the glitzy veneer of international airports in the UAE. It's time they did.

Tuesday, January 01, 2013

1-Jan-13: Prof. Cyril Karabus faces his thirteenth hearing in a United Arab Emirates court tomorrow

We're surely not the only people around who continue to watch with rising anger the things being done to the distinguished South African paediatrician, Prof. Cyril Karabus. 

We last wrote about the sordid matter a week ago - see "25-Dec-12: Update on the Emirates scandal". Please have a look at that post if you are not already familiar with the scandalous story so far.

Today's post is prompted by a news article that appeared on a South African news site yesterday [see "Blood money at root of charges"]. That was based on a phone interview Prof. Karabus gave to the Cape Times on Sunday. Here's the essence of it:

  • Prof. Karabus, aged 78 and frail, is due to appear in a United Arab Emirates court tomorrow, Wednesday, for the thirteenth time since he was arrested and then imprisoned. That was on August 18, 2012. 
  • At the time, he was in Dubai airport as a passenger on Qantas' new strategic partner, Emirate Airlines, passing through as a transit passenger after the wedding in Canada of one of his children. When he was arrested four and a half months ago, he had no knowledge that he faced prosecution in the United Arab Emirates, or that he had been ordered to pay a huge fine as "blood money". That's the name given to the payment by the court.
  • The nightmare arises from the fact that nearly a decade ago he treated a three-year-old Yemeni child called Sarah Adel Abdulla who was afflicted with acute myeloid leukemia. At that time, he was working as a locum at the the Sheikh Khalifa Medication Centre in Abu Dhabi. 
  • In 2004, after he had already left and gone back to South Africa, he was convicted in his absence and sentenced to four years’ jail. The allegation made to an empty court was that he had failed to give the child a blood transfusion and that he had falsified the child’s medical records to make it appear as if he had. 
  • The UAE prosecutors have produced no evidence to support these allegations. 
  • Nor have they managed to provide the court with the original medical files of the child who died. The prosecution did however deliver up photocopied pages purporting to be a copy of the original medicals. These pages, on inspection, turn out to show that the dead child had indeed been given a transfusion. Prof. Karabus has all along said that a transfusion was indeed given, and the criminal charge against him is bogus.
  • Prof. Karabus’s wife says the South African embassy has done nothing to help her husband other than to give him newspapers in prison and to arrange for its consul to attend court hearings.
  • The elderly doctor - in the words of the South African newspaper, an "eminent paediatrician" - was forced to sleep on a blanket on a bare concrete floor in the notorious Emirates prison called Al Wathba... for two months.
  • While he was imprisoned, and when he was brought to the court for the first few hearings (as we said above, tomorrow's will be the thirteenth), his legs and wrists were shackled in irons.
  • Since being (finally) granted bail after several abortive attempts, he has been the house guest of another South African resident in Abu Dhabi. That second doctor, Elwin Buchel, has recently been informed that his permit to work at a military hospital in Abu Dhabi, will not be renewed and he now has thirty days to leave the area.
Prof. Karabus, though free on bail, cannot leave the United Arab Emirates because his passport was seized at the time he was arrested. It continues to be held by the local authorities. 

We end this post with the same comment we made in our previous one. There's some sound advice in this South African Medical Association article for people traveling to the United Arab Emirates "in the naive belief that similar human rights protections to those they knew at home" will apply to them. 


It's information that the Australian airline Qantas might consider passing along to its passengers and customers. To understand why, please review another of our earlier posts: "15-Oct-12: Back to Dubai: Australian travelers might want to factor this report into their plans".