Daoud Kattoub, the Jordanian/Palestinian Arab journalist and media ‘activist’
(also a professor of journalism at Princeton University at some point in the past) writes on the
Al-Monitor website today [“Pre-OsloPrisoners Still Obstacle To Palestinian-Israeli Talks”] about the
heart-tugging issue of convicted murderers outrageously forced to remain behind bars.
Wait. In some ways it’s not as mad as it sounds. But yes, it
does sound quite insane if you’re not paying attention to the specific part of the world
in which it’s being played out.
Kattoub writes of men who, having been sent on military
missions by the leadership of Yasser Arafat’s blood-soaked PLO, are now “rotting in jail”
(Kattoub’s exact words) while promises allegedly made by various Israeli politicians to set them
free “have not been fulfilled”. These are the so-called pre-Oslo prisoners,
sometimes referred to in the ideologically-addled media as political prisoners.
There are a total of 118 of them inside Israel’s prisons today. (Other people speak of larger numbers. We're right; they are not.)
The issue reverberates, as Kattoub shows. The president
of Palestine, Mahmoud Abbas,
“has rejected an Israeli offer to have 50 of the
prisoners released. Abbas insists that all prisoners must be released as part
of a US-brokered agreement to restart face-to-face peace talks.” [Al-Monitor]
A serious issue, it seems. Fifty is not enough. Only the entire 118 will satisfy whatever deep need Abbas is addressing. And until they are out of jail, there can be no talks, no negotiation, no peace with Israel. He can take this purportedly high road because
“prisoners held for a long time… are held in high esteem
among Palestinians, as they have been paying such a high sacrifice for their
nation.” [Al-Monitor]
Let's analyse this a little.
The men whom Abbas has on his mind are from the group Kattoub disingenuously calls
the “more moderate Fatah faction”, who “feel that they have suffered because of
their party affiliation”. Not from Hamas. From Fatah, Abbas' group - the terrorists who report to him today.
Now in case the point slipped you by, almost all these 118 men are murderers; all convicted, all sentenced to lengthy murder-appropriate
terms in prison.
Kattoub knows this even while he conceals it from his readers. We looked
carefully through the table of the 118 names, and their crimes, their victims and their details. It’s a
sordid and ugly tabulation (the first-rate researchers at CAMERA published an English version of it here), with a not-insignificant number of the victims being fellow Arabs.
But most are, of course, Jews. And out of the 118 prisoners in the tally,
112 killed someone. The remaining six tried to kill, and were convicted of attempted
homicide. Political prisoners they are surely not, unless we have erased
homicide from our justice system. And we have not.
But some people have.
In an excellent overview on the CiF Watch site, published a
week ago (see “What the
Media Won’t Tell You About ‘Palestinian Prisoners’”), Adam Levick quotes
Harriet Sherwood’s April 9, 2013 report in the Guardian (UK) in which she writes about the “political
prisoners [Sherwood’s term] who have been in jail since before the
Oslo accords were signed almost 20 years ago”.
CiF Watch complained about this to The Guardian,
demonstrating that all the still-incarcerated pre-Oslo prisoners were convicted
of violence- and terrorism-based crimes. Sherwood’s report was revised after the fact (we didn't hear about any apology) to
note that it is only the Palestinians who view them as “political prisoners”. Of course far fewer Guardian readers saw the editorial correction than read the
original Harriet Sherwood outrage.
Now, in a simpler age and in other parts of the world, getting
prisoners out of jail traditional involves demonstrating that the price has
been paid, the lesson has been learned, justice has been served and it is time
to forgive and forget.
A series of incomprehensibly large, even vast, prisoner releases
made by Israel between 1985 and 2011 irrevocably changed all of that in this
part of the world.
Today, no serious observer even pretends that prisoners
should be let loose because they said sorry and promised not to do it again. At
least, not when we’re speaking of Palestinian Arab prisoners who were put away
because of acts of terror they inflicted on the despised and reviled Israelis. The template
has been created and the Palestinian Arabs and the Islamic world behind them fully
understand the new rules: that the Israeli prison system is filled with sons
and daughters of this transcendent thing called ‘resistance’ and Israel needs
to be (a) persuaded, (b) forced or (c) extorted to let them go free.
No one comprehends this better than the head of the PA,
Mahmoud Abbas. Often described as a moderate, he is quite the opposite to anyone paying attention. As an important analysis today by Khaled Abu Toameh on the Gatestone Institute website shows ["The Palestinian Authority's Reign of Terror"], he is a
doctrinaire manipulator of naked power, chiefly directed at the citizens he
purports to lead.
Abbas is in the ninth year of a four year term as president of a
political entity that has no functioning parliament, and that - while bankrupt, deeply in debt and perpetually penniless - finances a governmental ‘reward for terrorism’ scheme that
pays imprisoned murderers three or four times what it pays its own civil
servants. That’s not the whole of it, but merely the beginning. We will come
back to this.
The Abbas regime, currently pressing so hard for its veteran
murderer/prisoners to be let loose by the Israelis, does a cracker-jack job of telling
its own people why, and what it stands for. Here’s an illustration from the
past month that appears in today’s edition of the always-valuable Palestinian Media
Watch Bulletin.
Itamar Marcus and Nan Jacques Zilberdik, writing for PMW, report on how the Mahmoud Abbas PA regime chose two ways in the past month of expressing
honour and respect for a prisoner called Abdullah Barghouti. His is a name we
know well; he built the bomb-inside-a-guitar-case that exploded in Jerusalem’s
Sbarro restaurant on August 9, 2001. Among the fifteen people killed instantly was
our much-loved teenage daughter, Malki. 130 others were maimed and shattered, but survived.
One young woman was left unconscious, and remains unconscious until today. We
have written about this particular prisoner here in our blog repeatedly.
The despicable Abdullah Barghouti, convicted on 67 separate counts of murder, was honoured first by means of an
official “solidarity” visit to his family’s home. The PA Minister of Prisoners'
Affairs, Issa Karake, led the honour parade, accompanied the District Governor
of Ramallah, Laila Ghannam. Then the PA’s tightly controlled official
television channel arrived and recorded a video homage to Barghouti, including
interviews with proud family members.
The program host stated that Barghouti, who prepared
the bombs that killed 66 people, is "certainly a hero", and wished
for the fulfillment of "the purpose for which [the prisoners] are in fact
in the occupation's prisons." [PMW]
 |
Unrepentant mass murderer Abdullah Barghouti: Behind bars where he belongs, at least for now |
The host directly addressed the father of the unrepentant
mass murderer:
Father of Abdallah Barghouti, your son is certainly a
hero. We all think so, Allah willing they will live lives of freedom soon. All
their hopes and aspirations and the purpose for which they (i.e., the
prisoners) are in fact in the occupation's prisons, Allah willing, will be
fulfilled soon. [PMW]
Stop for a moment. Where else but in the society being constructed by the Palestinian Arabs, would a man who deliberately murdered 67 innocent civilians get this kind of lavish media attention? And be met with silence and utter indifference by the media professionals who know about it - and keep it out of their reports?
The sons and daughters of Palestinian Arab society are being
taught by their leaders and by their televisions that men and women like the psychopathic killers Abdullah Barghouti and Ahlam Tamimi are heroes. The actions that
got them locked away are a source of pride on a scale literally inconceivable
to people like us who live in democratic societies where law, order and justice
mean something.
So let’s clarify that when the Palestinian Arabs and their many
apologists call for the release of the Barghoutis and the Tamimis, their calls
are not for a pardon; if these killers of women and children had actually
asked for a pardon, we would be in a new world, a different era.
It’s not a
pardon they are requesting. It’s release for the sake of political expediency.
We really need you to do this, they say to Israel. We really, really have to
have these murderers out again because, look, they represent everything that’s
fine and great about the world we are building for our future generations. So just do it.
And if you were thinking perhaps that all of this might somehow be leading to peace and therefore is worth the pain and the effort, consider this: "Peace talks useless: Palestine leaders / June 12, 2013".
We say this: In the name of everything decent and sane, the demands for
cold-blooded, unrepentant killers to be let loose again must be answered with: that
would be massively unjust and we refuse in the names of our families and of the
children who continue to be your targets and theirs.
Now a few words about Norway.
Not everyone who tries to obscure
the true nature of Palestinian Arab society’s adoration of its baby-killers is
Palestinian Arab. We wrote about this phenomenon here a few weeks back, after visiting Scandinavia [see "22-May-13: Asking Norway to face up to the lethal consequences of its funding decisions" and before that "14-Mar-13: Shock! Horror! Norwegian politicians awaken to discover they were played for fools by the terrorists"].
Norway is a country of generous people. It gives more than (by far) most other states in order to do good. That, at least, is the plan. The reality is they are a major financial enabler of the appalling 'rewards for terror' program of Mahmoud Abbas. Norwegian money - along with French, British, German and Belgian money, all of it coming from unwitting tax payers and aid budgets - provides the family of the unspeakable mass murderer mentioned above with a monthly salary four times the size of a PA government worker's pay.
The European funding of Palestinian Arab terror is not at all new. Neither are the small and large lies that EU officials have been telling to their constituents, to the media and to themselves since at least 2002. Norway is now carrying out a long overdue self-examination to see who knew what and when. Their parliamentarians should be congratulated for being the first European government to do it, and parts of their media deserve full credit. They surely must not be allowed to be the last.
The Norwegians and other European funders of child killing have been able to get away with a hypocritical embrace of terrorism for so long because so many others - and first among them, the members of the news media - have allowed it. Harriet Sherwood will surely not be the last to write about the unrepentant killers of innocents as 'political prisoners'.
Those of us who can see where this leads have to ensure the people who make the political and editorial decisions know we are watching, that we will demand it stops, that we insist on respect for justice. Let the murderers remain in prison, and let those who seek to place them on a pedestal know of the revulsion the rest of us feel for their actions.
